Bookmark and Share

Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

Last post 06-03-2009 8:12 PM by Vincent Maurin. 7 replies.

Page 1 of 1 (8 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next

  • 06-03-2009 8:12 PM

    Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    So, as I'm sure I'm not the only one curious about this, what exactly was the Functional Completeness and Complexity criteria about? I mean, what was it exactly that the judges were looking for?

     

    And while I'm here, congratulations to the six finalists! :)

    "Make everything as simple as possible, but not simpler" ~ Albert Einstein

  • 06-03-2009 11:25 PM In reply to

    Re: Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    For judging process, we have given a mark to all 725 submissions (unfortunatly the leaderboard doesn't display the mark and the position for the 725 people). We have judged 4 parts : navigation outside the crater, navigation inside, rocks analysis and heatshield searching. For each part, we have given two marks, one for execution, one for the code (the code is a little bit more important that the execution).

    For the code we have given better mark to the most autonomous robot according the competition spirit  (for example, a robot that uses image processing and comlink data to get out the crater is better from a rover which uses a hard coded path to get out).

    Anyway, we have seen a lot of amazing things (all of judged submissions were 725 ones), the challenge was difficult, so congrulations all of you !

    Regards,

    Vincent

    Vincent Maurin
    Lead Software Engineer
    http://www.simplysim.net/
    http://www.robochamps.com/

  • 06-03-2009 11:50 PM In reply to

    Re: Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    I see. Thank you for the explanation Vincent :)

    I'm assuming that the "mark" given to the 725 people would be a grade or score or sorts.

    Would it be possible for the marks given to the 725 submissions be made public? Perhaps as a thread in this forum?

    I, and I'm pretty sure I'm not the only one, am rather curious to see how I fared.

    "Make everything as simple as possible, but not simpler" ~ Albert Einstein

  • 06-03-2009 11:51 PM In reply to

    Re: Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    great! vincent.

    could you display the mark here?

    thanks

  • 06-04-2009 12:00 AM In reply to

    Re: Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    carlosmiguelgomez:
    I'm assuming that the "mark" given to the 725 people would be a grade or score or sorts.

    My english isn't perfect :p Yes it's a score/grade/... (1 to 5 for each part)

    carlosmiguelgomez:
    Would it be possible for the marks given to the 725 submissions be made public? Perhaps as a thread in this forum?

    I really don't know, I will ask (and post them if I can)

    Regards,

    Vincent

    Vincent Maurin
    Lead Software Engineer
    http://www.simplysim.net/
    http://www.robochamps.com/

  • 06-04-2009 4:50 AM In reply to

    Re: Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    The ranking (name is form the package submitted, it's not the user name)

     

    1  -  zero.lin
    2  -  Aravinda DP
    3  -  Gauna
    4  -  Lucaso
    5  -  byronknoll
    6  -  Goldie
    7  -  siyuanzhou
    8  -  Evgeny
    9  -  Shuang sco_vera
    9  -  sanya_m
    11  -  Calio
    12  -  CarlosMiguelGomez
    12  -  ergys_ristani
    14  -  ruizc
    14  -  ChaoZhou
    16  -  ben_2151
    16  -  nagygergo
    18  -  AndreasSchierl
    18  -  PawelPodlasinski
    20  -  Clark
    21  -  wilianfc
    22  -  AgustinGutierrez
    22  -  Jeroen
    24  -  Riley_ikni
    24  -  Siwei200640276
    26  -  Jorge J Sanchez Fuentes
    26  -  YangYu
    28  -  LingThoth
    29  -  AlvaroFernandes
    30  -  ic09_francois_amato
    30  -  DanielLelis
    32  -  AnirbanChatterjee

    Anyway, you should receive more precision about your submission in the next couple weeks

    Vincent Maurin
    Lead Software Engineer
    http://www.simplysim.net/
    http://www.robochamps.com/

  • 06-04-2009 6:44 AM In reply to

    Re: Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    Vincent Maurin:

    carlosmiguelgomez:
    I'm assuming that the "mark" given to the 725 people would be a grade or score or sorts.

    My english isn't perfect :p Yes it's a score/grade/... (1 to 5 for each part)

     Oh, sorry if I came off as if I was criticizing your English Vincent :| not my intention, I was just clarifying.

     Thank you for posting the rankings :)

     

    Vincent Maurin:

    Anyway, you should receive more precision about your submission in the next couple weeks

     Oh, do you mean we'll get feedback on our entries? :D I was just thinking about this a while ago, if so, then brilliant! I was hoping for something like that so that we'd be able to learn a little more from this round :)

    Thanks again Vincent :)

    "Make everything as simple as possible, but not simpler" ~ Albert Einstein

  • 06-04-2009 11:21 PM In reply to

    Re: Functional Completeness and Complexity, what's it about? Vincent?

    Reply Contact

    Yes, you should receive an e-mail in the next couple of week

    Vincent Maurin
    Lead Software Engineer
    http://www.simplysim.net/
    http://www.robochamps.com/
Page 1 of 1 (8 items)